Disciplinary Investigations

HR Blog | HR Consultant | Bear HR

Disciplinary Investigations

In a case of misconduct, should you always carry out disciplinary investigations?

Our HR Consultants are regularly asked this question by clients.  The answer usually comes after asking the client a number of other questions.  However, the short answer is no, you don’t always have to hold  disciplinary investigations.

Where the misconduct is minor we would expect this to be addressed by the line manager on an informal one-to-one basis.  However, if the misconduct is such that disciplinary action seems likely, you should always consider whether a disciplinary investigation meeting need to take place first.

Where the matter is routine or straightforward there is probably no need to hold a disciplinary investigation meeting.  For example, if the matter relates to absence or timekeeping and you have a record of all absences or latenesses, it would be normal to just proceed to a disciplinary without further investigation.

When Disciplinary Investigations are necessary

Disciplinary Investigations | HR Consultant |Bear HR

It is likely, therefore, that the disciplinary investigations procedure will normally only be used in certain circumstances.  Perhaps if an employee is suspected of committed an act of serious misconduct or serious breach of your Company policies, procedures or rules.

The first step should be to decide who will conduct the disciplinary investigations. Next you should notify the employee as quickly as possible that they are under investigation and inform them who the Investigating Officer is.  Typically, the employee’s line manager would conduct the investigation but you may prefer to use a manager who is unconnected with the employee.

When appointing your Investigating Officer, please bear in mind that the person conducting the investigation should not be the same person as the person who will conduct any disciplinary that may be required.  The only exception to this is in very small businesses where it would not be practical for two different people to be involved.  However, in this case, the person involved must make every effort to remain impartial at all stages.

Alternatively an external HR Consultant can conduct the investigation for you with the utmost impartiality.

Suspension

Sometimes, the act of misconduct may be serious enough to warrant suspension during the disciplinary investigations.  Suspension should be a last resort and you should only impose a period of suspension after carefully considering whether it is necessary.  You should explain to the employee that it is not a disciplinary sanction and doesn’t affect the outcome of the investigation.  Any period of suspension must be for the shortest time possible and the employee should receive their normal salary throughout.

You may wish to stop the employee’s contact with other employees, customers / clients and suppliers during this time.   You should also make the employee aware that they need to be available at all times during their normal working hours in case the Investigating Officer needs to see them or speak to them about the disciplinary investigation.

Role of the Disciplinary Investigation Officer

Disciplinary Investigations | HR Consultant |Bear HR

In investigating the alleged misconduct, the Investigating Officer should: –

  • Examine any relevant written records, such as previous disciplinary warnings, appraisal records and manager’s notes.
  • Check whether there have been any earlier warnings that have not expired
  • Consult any other managers with whom the employee has come into contact to help establish the relevant facts
  • Talk privately and in confidence to any employees who may have evidence relating to the employees misconduct or who may have been witness to any relevant incident, and produce an accurate written summary of any such evidence
  • Seek the consent of any such employee to use the summary of the evidence they’ve given as a signed written statement (in certain circumstances it may be possible to present this anonymously, but please seek advice from us first)
  • Review all information given objectively and impartially. Avoid allowing personal views, opinions and personal preferences to influence your assessment of the employee’s conduct

Investigatory meeting with the employee

The investigating Officer may invite the employee to attend an investigatory meeting.  They should make it clear that the purpose of the meeting is to establish the facts and is not part of the disciplinary process.

After the meeting, the Investigating Officer should complete a written statement summarising the information provided by the employee.

There is no statutory right to be accompanied to an investigatory meeting but the Investigating Officer may consider a request from the employee to bring a work colleague to the meeting.

Once the investigation is complete, the Investigating Officer should decide whether or not it is appropriate to instigate disciplinary action against the employee.  Where they decide there is a disciplinary case to answer, the employee should be invited to attend a disciplinary hearing.

Any evidence obtained as part of the disciplinary investigation should be provided to the employee as part of an Evidence Pack when they are invited to the disciplinary meeting.  Witness statements, or a summary version, can be anonymised to conceal the identify of any of the parties if there is a legitimate reason to do so.

If it is decided not to take disciplinary action then the employee should be notified in writing of this decision as soon as possible, and certainly within five days of reaching the decision.

Keeping records from disciplinary investigations

Records relating to a disciplinary investigation should be held confidentially in the employee’s HR file in accordance with GDPR and any Data Retention Policy you have.  They are usually destroyed if it is decided not to instigate disciplinary action.  Information relating to a disciplinary investigation should only be accessed and disclosed for the purpose of completing the investigation and any subsequent disciplinary.

Our HR Consultants are always available to advise or even conduct a disciplinary investigation on your behalf.

Contact us to find out more.

Logo | HR Consultants | Bear HR
  • Trade Union Right to Access

    What’s happening This is still draft legislation at the time of writing but we expect that on 30 October the Employment Rights Act will introduce a new piece of legislation. If you employ 21 or more people you should be preparing for this change to legislation now as Trade Unions will have the right to…

    Read More

  • ALL Reasonable Steps to Prevent Sexual Harassment

    ALL Reasonable Steps to Prevent Sexual Harassment

    “All” is such a small word, but it is about a have a huge meaning as employers face a new duty to take ALL reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment in the workplace. Current situation Since October 2024, employers have been under an obligation to take reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment in the workplace.…

    Read More

  • Succession Planning Case Study Stepping Stones to Success

    Succession Planning Case Study Stepping Stones to Success

    Case Study · Construction Sector Succession Planning · Workforce Development

    Read More

  • Transforming Absence Management and Reducing Costs by 83%

    Transforming Absence Management and Reducing Costs by 83%

    Background A manufacturing business with 160 employees approached Bear HR for support after recognising significant operational disruption caused by unmanaged employee absence. The organisation had never had a dedicated HR function, and attendance processes were inconsistent, informal, and largely reactive. The Challenge The business faced growing concerns around productivity, cost control, and workforce accountability due…

    Read More