Tag: Worker

  • Employment Status

    Employment Status | HR Consultant | Bear HR

    Employment Status is more than what the Contract says

    Last month the Supreme Court ruled that the employment status of Uber drivers is that of workers and not self-employed.  This means they are entitled to be receive a number of benefits:

    • National Minimum Wage,
    • Paid holidays,
    • Statutory rest breaks,
    • Protection from discrimination and whistleblowing,
    • Auto-enrolment onto a pension scheme.

    This is likely to have significant impact on the gig economy and other businesses who use self-employed contractors.

    It is not enough to just have an agreement or contract in place that says the individual carries out work on a self-employed basis.  HMRC use a number of tests to determine Employment Status for tax purposes.

    HMRC Employment Status test questions

    If you’re not sure whether a contractor you’ve hired should really be a worker or employee, answering these questions should help you decide:

    • Are they in business for themselves, with responsibility for the success or failure of their business and able to make a loss or a profit
    • Can they decide what work they do and when, where or how to do it
    • Can they hire someone else to do the work
    • Are they responsible for fixing any unsatisfactory work in their own time
    • Does the employer or engager agrees a fixed price for their work that doesn’t depend on how long the job takes to finish
    • Do they use their own money to buy business assets, cover running costs, and provide tools and equipment for their work
    • Can they work for more than one client

    The HMRC online tool can help make an impartial decision and can be completed anonymously.

    Social Media Recruitment | HR Consultants | Bear HR

    Uber Supreme Court Ruling

    Uber used written agreements between themselves and the drivers to support their defence.  However this was rejected by the Supreme Court on the basis that whether a contract is a “worker’s contract” is not decided by applying ordinary principles of contract law.  The Supreme Court went on to state that the written term did not reflect the reality of the agreement.  Therefore, tribunals and courts should look outside the terms to determine the actual employment status.

    The Supreme Court cited five key findings that justified its conclusion that Uber drivers are workers.

    Key findings

    • Fares for journeys that are booked through the Uber app are determined by Uber.  Drivers are not not permitted to charge more than the Uber fare.
    • The drivers perform their services on contractual terms dictated by Uber and have no say on the terms.
    • Drivers do have the freedom to choose when and where to work.  However, their choice is restricted once they log into the Uber app. Significantly, drivers do not know the passengers destination until they are picked up.  This means they are not able to decline a booking to a particular destination.
    • Uber exercises a significant degree of control over the way in which drivers deliver their services.   If the driver’s passenger satisfaction ratings fall below a certain level, Uber may terminate its relationship with the driver.  The Supreme Court described this as a “potent method of control”
    • Uber restricts communication between a passenger and a driver, which prevents drivers from establishing any relationship with a passenger capable of extending beyond an individual ride.

    In conclusion the Supreme Court said that once logged onto the Uber app, the service performed by the driver is “very tightly defined and controlled by Uber” with the drivers in a position of “subordination and dependency.”

    The Supreme Court upheld the tribunal’s decision that the drivers are “workers” during any period they are logged onto the Uber app.

    Next steps for business owners

    If you own or run a business in the gig economy or regularly use subcontractors, we recommend you review the agreements you have in place against the HMRC test questions.  You should ensure they reflect the reality of the situation.  Remember, courts and tribunals will look beyond the contractual wording when deciding whether an individual is a worker or self-employed.

    Contact our HR Consultants if you would like any advice in determining the employment status of individuals who provide services to your business.